Friday, May 20, 2016

MoCo Council budget: So easy, a caveman could do it

As Paul Harvey used to say: "And now...the rest of the story." While the Montgomery County political cartel is congratulating itself on the biggest heist of County residents' money in history, it is indeed time for the rest of the story on the Montgomery County Council's FY-2017 budget disaster.

Being sold as an "Education First" budget, it is in fact exactly like every other budget this Council has passed, except costing you a lot more than ever before. Forget that the Council has just robbed your bank account, or is slamming the working family trying to refinance their mortgage with a recordation tax. The budget that pulls off the 100 Maryland Avenue equivalent of The Italian Job promises to flush $90 million more down the Montgomery County Public Schools toilet, where schools have been in decline since 2010 according to the report by the Office of Legislative Oversight.

Great. But how does that make any sense without a definitively new plan to spend it? The budget will reduce class sizes by 1 or 2 students at some schools. It will add more auxiliary personnel, not actual teachers. But that's it. There's no new strategy to tackle the achievement gap here, just more expensive deck chairs being added to the Titanic.

Where is the universal Pre-K? Where are the additional early education initiatives? Where are the new partnerships with high-wage employers? Hint, none of these sure-fire solutions to the achievement gap are in this massive tax hike budget.

We will only have standardized tests to gauge student results at this point. I agree that testing has been oversold in recent decades. But, ironically, by recently dumbing down its grading system and eliminating final exams, MCPS has only now increased the importance of standardized test scores. If all of the classroom work is going to be graded with the new powder puff grading scale, grades are almost certain to rise across the board. That's not improvement, nor is it how education works. Outside of MCPS, such tactics are correctly termed, "cheating."

As far as school construction funds generated, note that the Council is raising those funds from you, not from the developers who are creating the need for more classrooms and schools. They didn't have the guts to go after the developers who provide 80% of their campaign funds, but they were eager and ready to pick your pocket.

Moreover, the Council has just dug us deeper into the structural deficit hole that we already had no immediate ability to climb out of. By going so far over the Maintenance of Effort requirement, we will now be required to match or exceed that level of spending next year, and in perpetuity. This was not leadership. It was a reckless, irresponsible vote passed to cover the Council's fiscal irresponsibility over the last two decades.

Did the Council make "history," as they claimed? Yes, in two regards: They have finally triggered the ultimate tax revolt, by unanimously voting to exceed the charter limit. The brilliance of the Ficker Amendment that created that cap is that each councilmember becomes the deciding vote when all 9 agree to exceed the cap.

And secondly, Council President Nancy Floreen made history by giving the longest speech regarding the passage of a budget I've ever heard. Ms. Floreen and her colleagues should probably save their "emotional" speeches for the 2018 election, when they have to actually face the voters.

Most disgustingly, the Council is the only player in this budget that slithers away with no skin in the game. They didn't give up any of their pet projects or spending that goes towards their political patrons. They sure as heck didn't give up any of the money they funnel to their developer puppet masters.

All they did was pick the pocket of the taxpayer, rob your bank account, and kneecap County employees by breaking signed labor contracts the Council had agreed to pay. Even a caveman could do that. I've heard complaints from individual teachers, first responders and other County employees. But where are the comments from union leaders in the County? Where's the outrage? This was a horrible deal, and a horrible precedent for labor. If you want to limit wages, that's something you proactively do when you negotiate and approve labor contracts. Breaking contracts is beyond the pale.

Being an incompetent councilmember, and then robbing the taxpayer and County employees to make up for it, is not leadership. It is not ingenious. It is not wise. It is cowardice. It is impotence. It is contempt for your constituents. It is a firing offense.

The term limit petition proposed for the ballot this fall may give voters the chance to give at least a few of the pink slips this Council so richly deserves.


  1. Everything in this post is accurate. MoCo is in decline and has been in decline for a number of years now and all our county council knows how to do is tax and spend to get out of it.

  2. Yes, MoCo's crime rate is in decline, MoCo's unemployment rate is in decline, MoCo's office vacancy rate is in decline.... Unfortunately, things like MCPS graduation rate, home values, and per capita income aren't in decline, though. :(

    1. 10:05: Wrong! Serious crime was up last year, unemployment rate mostly reflects jobs outside of the County, and MCPS exam scores are DOWN, while the achievement gap has GROWN. Take off your distortion lenses and examine the sad state of a wealthy, highly educated County with amateur hour councilmembers.

    2. "Wrong!" Are you illiterate? We're talking about the past "number of years." No one even marginally educated can look at the last 5 or 10 or 20 years and say crime has gone up in the county. You plucking one category of one year shows how desperate you are to distort reality.

      Exam scores? MoCo and MD have the best AP marks in the entire country. How do you write a blog, yet not even know basic crime trends and test rankings for the county you pretend to know?

    3. 12:19: I'm referring to course exams, not standardized test scores - you know, the final exams that such a large percentage of students couldn't pass that - over teachers' objections - MCPS has simply gotten rid of them.

      You brought up crime, not me, and the fact is that gangs and serious crime are on an upward trend in the last year.

  3. A couple of points. 1st, teachers agreed to freeze previously negotiated pay increases during the recession while the school population has increased. At the time, most cuts that were made affected non-teaching staff and class sizes still rose. Health care costs by teachers also increase. 2nd, which studies indicated that partnerships with high wage employers make measurable differences in student performance or success? 3rd, I agree the new grading system is inane, I think the system was well intentioned, but needs lots of tinkering. 4th, what data do you have to support the claim that new housing is the reason the county has more students? To what extent do you think student population has increased due to the recession (private school becoming less affordable), or the lack of code enforcement regarding overcrowded housing? 5th, MCPS does have the best AP scores while increasing the number of minorities taking those tests, so it must be doing something right. 6th, I think we need to talk more about the need to change school boundaries.

  4. my fingers smell like cheese.